The accountancy profession needs to present itself in a manner more directly identifiable with the benefits it can bring, says Steve Benham. The ability to predict profitability is vital – and technology, data and an agile forecast process are your tools.
Chief accountant, business partner, financial controller, finance director, CFO: all titles typically given to us accountants. The problem is that, for our non-accountant colleagues, these titles don’t encapsulate what’s important about our role.
One of my best bosses, the late chef Albert Roux, used to lovingly call me his bean counter. Although that was in the 1980s, I suspect many executives still view us that way. How do we change this perception? We need to focus more on what the executive team really needs from us.
In a later CFO role, I was proud to reduce the financial close to five working days and to add a commentary to the accounts – quite novel in those days. The CEO’s response was succinct: “Don’t tell me about over/under accruals – that’s accountants’ jargon. Don’t tell me about variances between plan and actuals. I signed the purchase order two months ago and I knew then we were going to exceed budget on advertising. I need you to give me your best view of future profitability, then I can make informed decisions about future production, future products and future customer pricing.” A good lesson for a young CFO.
I have come to the conclusion that very few finance departments can explain the causes of profitability to their non-accountant colleagues. They are even less able to articulate forecast profitability. Yet executive decisions are about improving future profitability, so there should be a finance role that focuses on that. Finance transformation should therefore start with the appointment of a Future Profit Officer (FPO). The focus is then clear to all.
Only in recent years have I begun to see CFOs change focus towards future profit. One of my clients needed to move rapidly from research and development mode to product marketing and manufacturing mode, and needed to raise significant private equity to do so. Rather than getting bogged down in reporting monthly expenditure, the CFO commissioned a financial model where a five-year plan was updated in real time by changes to sales forecasts derived from the e-sales data, and also by changes in production planning. The latter allowed batches to be planned bottom-up, using bill of materials functionality and a 16-step supply chain across two factories and three countries.
Using this model, the CFO was able to fulfil successive private equity requests to see different scenarios, normally within a few hours. He was also able to produce business-as-usual forecasts for executive decision-making. Only after six months or so did they start populating the reports with actual results. It gave them comfort, of course, but didn’t change any decisions. FPO in action.
Finance transformation should therefore start with the appointment of a Future Profit Officer (FPO). The focus is then clear to all.
Defining the role to focus on future profitability is vital, but to be successful there are other challenges.
None of this will happen, however, unless accountants grasp the nettle by focusing on future profitability rather than analysis of historic numbers. Let’s start by appointing FPOs so that the business community at least knows what our mission is.
Case study: Transforming your approach to forecasting
Twelve months after committing with its new investors to developing a three-year plan, the directors of this newly formed global software provider were under pressure to deliver. The new CFO had only historic management and statutory accounts to go on, prepared by a finance department operating with an unstable network of disconnected spreadsheets and legacy IT tools.
As a first step, an FPO was appointed. This role gave the focus necessary to bring all the key components together. That included a future-looking cause-and-effect model and redesigning the cross-departmental planning process, both enabled by the purchase of cloud-based planning and modelling software. The three-year plan including profit and loss analysis by region, channel and product, integrated with balance sheet and cash flow, was delivered in about six weeks in late 2019.
With investors satisfied, the FPO was able to move on to deal with other problems highlighted by the three-year plan. With a global team of account executives using only spreadsheets, the Chief Sales Officer (CSO) was struggling to provide timely and reliable sales forecasts. The model was expanded to provide granularity down to sales territory level, and a daily update of committee sales from the sales pipeline management system.
The CSO was delighted, as he now had up-to-date information with which to manage the sales team at an operational level. Just as important was that finance now had reliable sales forecasts, already integrated with a forecast version of the three-year plan, to use as a basis for rolling forecasts.
During 2020, the FPO was instrumental in delivering reliable sales forecasts, a sales target and quota management functionality, and sales commission forecasting – one of the biggest and previously unpredictable costs. The CSO now has a sales operations planning system and the CFO can see the impact of changes on corporate finances almost immediately.
By using the three-year plan as the base, and by redesigning the quarterly rolling forecast process, the FPO is now delivering regular forecasts. Finance can also now respond quickly to ad-hoc requests for analysis and scenarios. There is more to do, such as including the monthly performance results, and connecting an operations model for product development and IT projects to the base cause-and-effect model. It is clear, however, that the focus provided by appointing an FPO, a little over 12 months later, has enabled more agile executive decision-making based on the latest view of the future.
Further reading
The ICAEW Library & Information Service provides access to leading business, finance and management journals, as well as eBooks.
Further reading on improving profitability and forecasting is available through the resources below.
You are permitted to access articles subject to the terms of use set by our suppliers and any restrictions imposed by individual publishers. Please see individual supplier pages for full terms of use.
Terms of use: You are permitted to access, download, copy, or print out content from eBooks for your own research or study only, subject to the terms of use set by our suppliers and any restrictions imposed by individual publishers. Please see individual supplier pages for full terms of use.
More support on business
Read our articles, eBooks, reports and guides on Financial management
Financial management hubFinancial management eBooksCan't find what you're looking for?
The ICAEW Library can give you the right information from trustworthy, professional sources that aren't freely available online. Contact us for expert help with your enquiries and research.
-
Update History
- 17 Mar 2021 (12: 00 AM GMT)
- First published
- 20 Mar 2023 (12: 00 AM GMT)
- Page updated with Further reading section, adding related resources on improving profitability and forecasting. These additional articles and eBook provide fresh insights, case studies and perspectives on this topic. Please note that the original article from 2021 has not undergone any review or updates